Is providing your photography for free a way to begin a career as a professional photographer?
That’s the question that arose while watching a recent conversation (see video below) conducted by Zack Arias with Mikael Cho, the founder, and owner of Unsplash. Unsplash is a platform where photographers submit their images for use by anyone for free including commercial use without financial compensation or even attribution to the photographer.
Arias was both surprised and angry at a service he believed contributed to the continued devaluing of photography and photographers. It’s an issue that has been a concern for photographers who have increasingly faced reduced earnings for their work whether shooting stock, editorial or commercial. But rather than adding another angry voice to the chorus, Arias sought out Cho to have a discussion about how it might be or not be a great thing for photographers. It’s worth the watch.
First off, props to both Arias and Cho for having this conversation and sharing it publicly. In a time were civil debate seems a lost art, both of these men had a frank and honest conversation. It provides some valuable insight that is important to understand when contributing to such a service including concerns over liability.
While Arias explained how the licensing of images is the means by which a commercial photographer earns his living, Cho countered that there are many clients who because of the cost of such licenses are prohibited from being able to use such work. Hence Unsplash provides designers access to quality images that otherwise would not be available to them. Though photographers aren’t compensated, the hope is that relationships will be built which may result in future collaborations where photographers can earn money for their work. It’s about building relationships rather than immediately earning money. It’s short-term loss for long-term gain.
This is the supposed new model. Rather than building a body of work, accumulating clients through cold-calling and in-person meetings, a photographer gains access to a larger audience and potential clients. Granted these potential clients wouldn’t pay anything, to begin with, but if the work is good and a relationship is built, a paid opportunity might eventually be on the horizon. It’s sort of the YouTube model of marketing where you produce free content, build an audience and eventually find a way to monetize that audience. But what may work in the world of social influencers does not automatically translate to a business that is based on providing a service.
I think that applying such an approach to marketing and producing paid opportunities is flawed and that leads me to the question. Are there any photographers who have actually built a successful professional career in this way? I’m not talking about the photographer who may have made a contact and earned a job here or there from the resulting work. Rather, are there examples of photographers who converted such users into paying clients and have succeeded in building a sustainable business? Or is this simply the cliched argument that tries to convince a photographer that exposure is more valuable to their career than a check?
I am doubtful of that because my experiences have demonstrated that once a client can afford to pay a photographer for their services, they don’t go back to the photographer that worked for them for free. They prefer to work with a photographer who they feel will provide them value for their money. The photographer who has valued their work at zero provides no value in that equation. As with many things we spend our money on, we want to know that were are getting the most for our money and that includes photography.
The lure of working for free is often been seen by new photographers as the means to get the foot in the door. And while you might be able to get the foot in the door that doesn’t mean that you get invited to the party.
There is no doubt that platforms like this will continue to arise and that thousands of photographers will readily contribute to them. However, does a platform like Unsplash provide a provable means to earn a living as photographer? Or is it just another source for free photography which promises momentary exposure and slim possibilities.
Nick Carver is a working photographer and photography instructor based in Southern California with over eighteen years shooting experience and a professional career spanning more than a decade. Although his teaching and commercial work hinges primarily on digital photography, his passion is fueled by a love for analog film and creating fine art prints. Nick has sought to educate, entertain, and inspire other photographers both in the classroom and through his YouTube videos.
Robbie Quinn is an award-winning, New York–based commercial photographer specializing in environmental portraits. His work, which has brought him to more than a dozen countries, speaks to current issues, including race, immigration, gender identity, and sexual orientation, emphasizing promoting diversity and inclusion.
Rachelle Steele is a Master Photographer based out of Northern California. She is most known for dynamic black and white environmental portraiture and her ability to fill a single frame with design elements of intense storytelling and passionate compositions. Her unique background brings depth and power to her images, communicating something from the eye, heart, and mind.
Joel Meyerowtiz is an award-winning photographer whose work has appeared in over 350 exhibitions in museums and galleries worldwide. Celebrated as a pioneer of color photography, he is a two-time Guggenheim Fellow, a recipient of both the National Endowment for the Arts and National Endowment for the Humanities awards and The Royal Society’s Centenary Medal. He has published over 53 books. His latest release is titled. The Pleasure of Seeing.
Kirsten Elstner is the founder and director of National Geographic Photo Camp, whose mission is to work with youth from diverse communities worldwide, guiding them as they use photography to tell their own stories and develop meaningful connections with others.
George Lange is a photographer whose pictures have appeared in almost all major magazines, ranging from Entertainment Weekly to Esquire. George has shot advertising photos for many movies and TV shows, including; Seinfeld, The Today Show, Cake Boss, and Jim Carrey’s movies. Most recently, he has worked with Norwest Venture Partners, Twilio, the Richard King Mellon Foundation, and the Grammy Award-winning Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra. George's new book, Picturing Joy: Stories of Connection, is a lively guide to George’s approach to life and the highlights of his career.
Michael Honegger is a visual artist born in Germany with a B.A. in History & Spanish from Duke University, a M.S. in Foreign Service from Georgetown University, and a Professional Certificate in Visual Arts from Maine Media College. His practice as a fine art and documentary photographer explores the performative nature of self-portraiture, the complexities of memory and family, and an investigation of the ironies of American culture with an expatriate’s eye. His most recent book is The Need to Know.
Barbara Mensch is a fine art photographer who probes her subject matter with the curiosity and stamina of a detective. Born in Brooklyn, New York, she began to draw at an early age, attending classes at The Brooklyn Museum Studio School and the Art Students League as a teenager.
James Payne is a social documentary photographer based in Los Angeles, California.
He is fascinated by how people interact with the places they inhabit, particularly in their homes and on the streets. He has been capturing images of both for decades. American Portraits (in 3D) are a unique series of environmental portraits that are rendered in three dimension using his own approach for showcasing these images.
Jorge Delgado-Ureña is a photographer and the co-founder of The Raw Society. Originally a commercial and fashion photographer, an assignment in Nepal opened up a whole new world of photography and inspired him to create The Raw Society.
Christelle Enquist is a photographer and co-founder of The Raw Society. She speaks four languages and was raised in Singapore; her curiosity about other cultures and passion for travel started at an early age, instigated by her mother and father. A 6-month solo travel at 33 awoke her passion for photography.
Sandy Sugawara and Catiana Garcia Kilroy collaborate on a book project titled Show Me the Way Home. It is an immersive, visual journey through the incarceration camps that held 120,000 Japanese Americans during World War 2. Sugawara and Kilroy tell the story of each camp through original and archival photographs, personal stories, and government documents. It’s a frightening tale of a society that failed to protect its vulnerable.
Jason Langer is an American photographer best known for his psychological and norish visions of contemporary photography urban life. Langer apprenticed with renowned photographers including Ruth Bernhard, Arthur Tess, and Michael Kenna. Langer is known for his fine-art black-and-white photography. His latest book is titled Berlin.
Richard Sandler is a street photographer and documentary filmmaker. He has directed and shot eight non-fiction films, including “The Gods of Times Square,” “Brave New York,” and “Radioactive City.”
Nina Welch-Kling is a New York City-based photographer originally from a small town in southern Germany. Her background in fine art and architecture, combined with a love for roaming the city streets, inform her photographic depictions of everyday life.
Raquel Natalicchio is a photographer from Los Angeles, CA, now based in Houston, TX as a staff visual journalist for The Houston Chronicle. Raquel documents social issues, community-driven stories, political mobilization, and migration across the US/Mexico border. Her work focuses on the universality of humanity, including themes of love, struggle, resilience, and community.
Bob Patterson is the founder and publisher of Street Photography Magazine. For the past 10 years, Bob has produced a magazine dedicated to showcasing a diverse range of street photography and documentary photographers. An early adopter of digital publications, Bob combined his savvy for web design with his personal love for photography.
Larry Niehues is a French-born author and photographer who immigrated to the United States in 2010. While working as a commercial photographer for a variety of brands and publications, Mr. Niehues has tended to his passion for motorcycles, music, and the open road, traveling intensively over the last seven years creating the images that compose Nothing Has Changed, a photographic journey across America that connects the present with the past in ways that make us contemplate our collective future. His latest book is Mississippi Dream.
After graduating from California State University, Los Angeles with a Master of Arts Degree in Pictorial/Documentary History, Mark Edward Harris started his professional photography career doing the stills for the Merv Griffin Show and various television and movie companies. Mark has worked on numerous documentary projects. His latest project focuses on the challenges of orangutans, their habitat, and the people that are helping them to survive.
Matthew Jordan Smith is an American photographer based in Tokyo, Japan and working between Tokyo, New York City and Los Angeles. He has photographed some of the worlds most famous celebrities including Oprah Winfrey, Queen Latifah, Angela Bassett, Tyra Banks and more. His advertising clients include Olay, Pantene, Revlon, Showtime and HBO.
Barbara Peacock is a photographer and director living in Portland, Maine. Since having started American Bedroom in 2016, she has won the Getty Editorial Grant, the Women Photograph/Getty Grant, three LensCulture Awards, four Top 50 Critical Mass Awards, and was named one of the Top 100 Photographers in America 2020.